#DV2020 #DV2021 #Gomez #Rai #Goodluck update: Government reports IT system updates are ready. But we have questions. They don’t mention KCC and they pull this 36,872 number out of thin air.
We don’t know where they got that. We are asking.
Reminder: no reserved unused DV20 or DV21 visas can be issued until we beat the appeal.
(And for GL- also win summary judgment)
We don’t know where they got that. We are asking.
Reminder: no reserved unused DV20 or DV21 visas can be issued until we beat the appeal.
(And for GL- also win summary judgment)
Morrison Urena, LC
#DV2020 #DV2021 #Gomez #Rai #Goodluck update: Government reports IT system updates are ready. But we have questions. They don’t mention KCC and they pull this 36,872 number out of thin air. We don’t know where they got that. We are asking. Reminder: no reserved…
Screen Shot 2022-07-22 at 10.39.13 AM.png
673.8 KB
2022.07.22 Letter concerning oral argument format.pdf
60.6 KB
#DV2020 #DV2021 Update: On July 22, 2022, the clerk for the appeals court posted this letter concerning oral argument format. Basically, there are dozens of attorneys representing thousands of DV2020 and DV2021 plaintiffs across multiple lawsuits whose appeals share this consolidated hearing. In the interest of efficiency, the appeals court does not want to hear from every attorney. We will confer with counsel in the other lawsuits and work on a response to this filing by the August 12 deadline.
2022_12_2022_Goodluck_Appeal_Parties'_Response_regarding_oral_argument.pdf
337.1 KB
#DV2020 #DV2021 Goodluck/Gomez/Rai Appeal update: the parties have filed a response to the clerk's request for oral argument format.
Note: Ok.. so we have a hearing in September in the appeal. We will have a limited amount of time before the 3-judge panel. These are two proposals on how that time is used.
Note: Ok.. so we have a hearing in September in the appeal. We will have a limited amount of time before the 3-judge panel. These are two proposals on how that time is used.
#DV2020 #DV2021 Update: the 3-judge panel for the Goodluck/Goh, Gomez, and Rai appeal has been selected:
•Chief Judge Sri Srinivasan (appointed by Obama)
•Judge Karen Henderson (appointed by GWB)
•Judge Gregory Katsas (appointed by Trump)
EXTREMELY IMPORTANT NOTE: I don't want to hear that any of my clients tried to contact any of these judges directly. That kind of contact is prohibited and could cause us a lot of problems.
•Chief Judge Sri Srinivasan (appointed by Obama)
•Judge Karen Henderson (appointed by GWB)
•Judge Gregory Katsas (appointed by Trump)
EXTREMELY IMPORTANT NOTE: I don't want to hear that any of my clients tried to contact any of these judges directly. That kind of contact is prohibited and could cause us a lot of problems.
2022.08.23 Goodluck:Gomez:Rai appeal order on format.pdf
57.1 KB
#DV2020 #DV2021 Goodluck/Gomez/Rai Update: the court has issued this order laying how the format for who will be making arguments on September 16, and for how long.
Our Rafael Urena will be briefing three issues:
Issues:
1) State's prioritization of other visa categories above DVs
2) the Rai order's relief to non-plaintiffs
3) standing of DV2021 plaintiffs who court initially found lack standing
Our Rafael Urena will be briefing three issues:
Issues:
1) State's prioritization of other visa categories above DVs
2) the Rai order's relief to non-plaintiffs
3) standing of DV2021 plaintiffs who court initially found lack standing
#DV2020 #DV2021 FAQ: How long does DC Circuit take to rule on appeal after the hearing?
Answer: “Three months from oral argument is what the judges shoot for…”
- Retired Judge Thomas B. Griffith
https://www.yalejreg.com/nc/5553/
Answer: “Three months from oral argument is what the judges shoot for…”
- Retired Judge Thomas B. Griffith
https://www.yalejreg.com/nc/5553/
Yale Journal on Regulation
D.C. Circuit Review – Reviewed: One Step, Two Step? It Was Well Worth the Wait. - Yale Journal on Regulation
At my investiture, I confessed that I had long been in awe of the judges on the D.C. Circuit who were now my colleagues. Caveat lector: Nothing changed during the fifteen years that I served alongside them. Which means that my contributions to the D.C. Circuit…
#DV2020 #DV2021 FAQ: How can the Circuit Court of Appeals made a decision after just one short hearing on Sept. 16?
Answer: Oral arguments are only one component of an appeal. Most of the arguments are covered in depth in the papers- thousands of pages in the Gomez/Goodluck/Goh/Rai appeals. You can find those filings under under Goodluck appeal on our website: https://morrisonurena.com/goodluck-v-biden
Answer: Oral arguments are only one component of an appeal. Most of the arguments are covered in depth in the papers- thousands of pages in the Gomez/Goodluck/Goh/Rai appeals. You can find those filings under under Goodluck appeal on our website: https://morrisonurena.com/goodluck-v-biden
2022.09.14 Goodluck appeal- gov letter.pdf
157.9 KB
#DV2020 #DV2021 Update: this is the DIRECT link to stream oral arguments in Friday's appeal hearing: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HupkhJc7_fU
YouTube
The United States Court of Appeals for the DC Circuit
Friday, September 16, 2022 9:30 A.M. USCA (Live-Stream)
Judges Srinivasan, Henderson, Katsas
Case#: 21-5263 Maxwell Goodluck v. Joseph Biden, Jr. (See Order for Details)
Case#: 21-5256 Andi Gjoci v. DOS (See Order for Details)
Case#: 21-5231 Antanina…
Judges Srinivasan, Henderson, Katsas
Case#: 21-5263 Maxwell Goodluck v. Joseph Biden, Jr. (See Order for Details)
Case#: 21-5256 Andi Gjoci v. DOS (See Order for Details)
Case#: 21-5231 Antanina…
FAQ: What are the issues at play in tomorrow's hearing of Biden admin appeals of pro-immigrant orders?
Answer:
Gomez v Biden: https://drive.google.com/file/d/1JuIPUD2EWjyweQ_fmzdWwmuWzjlBF7Q3/view
Rai v Biden: https://drive.google.com/file/d/1H9dx7-GKP_rjCtFjoRasEIzTFghBNYuB/view
Goodluck v Biden: https://drive.google.com/file/d/1eMK2D5KXDQlUdsV_cXZvY0OJ_n-3Puy3/view
#DV2020 #DV2021
Answer:
Gomez v Biden: https://drive.google.com/file/d/1JuIPUD2EWjyweQ_fmzdWwmuWzjlBF7Q3/view
Rai v Biden: https://drive.google.com/file/d/1H9dx7-GKP_rjCtFjoRasEIzTFghBNYuB/view
Goodluck v Biden: https://drive.google.com/file/d/1eMK2D5KXDQlUdsV_cXZvY0OJ_n-3Puy3/view
#DV2020 #DV2021
71_UAO_Plaintiffs'_Reply_in_Support_of_Second_Motion_for_Preliminary.pdf
169.9 KB
#UAOvBiden #DV2021: we have filed plaintiffs' reply in support of second motion for preliminary injunction (the motion where we ask Judge Chang to preserve unused visas and retain plaintiffs' eligibility for them). Now it is up to Judge Chang to issue an order on the motion. We do not know when that answer will come, but we are optimistic it will come by September 30.
#DV2020 #DV2021 Gomez/Goodluck/Rai appeal reminder: 10 minutes to showtime! Already, 161listeners are waiting to audio stream oral arguments:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HupkhJc7_fU
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HupkhJc7_fU
YouTube
The United States Court of Appeals for the DC Circuit
Friday, September 16, 2022 9:30 A.M. USCA (Live-Stream)
Judges Srinivasan, Henderson, Katsas
Case#: 21-5263 Maxwell Goodluck v. Joseph Biden, Jr. (See Order for Details)
Case#: 21-5256 Andi Gjoci v. DOS (See Order for Details)
Case#: 21-5231 Antanina…
Judges Srinivasan, Henderson, Katsas
Case#: 21-5263 Maxwell Goodluck v. Joseph Biden, Jr. (See Order for Details)
Case#: 21-5256 Andi Gjoci v. DOS (See Order for Details)
Case#: 21-5231 Antanina…
This is Curtis. I'm going to tweet about #DV2020 #DV2021 Gomez/Goodluck/Rai appeal hearing on this thread: https://twitter.com/curtismorrison/status/1570768257044598785?s=20&t=5Bdz73TlWkVPTA8KYe41ew
X (formerly Twitter)
Curtis Morrison (@curtismorrison) on X
Ms. Alterberg, on behalf of @JoeBiden administration, opens her arguments by defending the Trump administration's anti-immigrant policies, blaming them instead on the Covid pandemic. Unbelievable.
2022_09_16_Goodluck_appeal_COURTROOM_MINUTES_OF_ORAL_ARGUMENT.pdf
54 KB
#DV2020 #DV2021 (Gomez/Goodluck/Rai appeal)
If you missed this morning's appeal hearing, you can access from the archive: https://www.cadc.uscourts.gov/recordings/recordings2022.nsf/51F2CAD380DB9FD8852588BF005B3D04/$file/21-5263%20and%2021-5256%20and%2021-5231.mp3
If you missed this morning's appeal hearing, you can access from the archive: https://www.cadc.uscourts.gov/recordings/recordings2022.nsf/51F2CAD380DB9FD8852588BF005B3D04/$file/21-5263%20and%2021-5256%20and%2021-5231.mp3