accuse your opponent of monopoly power -> use that accusation to justify creating actual monopoly power -> dress the new monopoly in democratic legitimacy language -> achieve the centralisation you accused them of
thats Zuboff’s move in the book, ‘Surveillance Capitalism’ - which completely fails to point the finger at the central bank empire.
i know, i know - do try to appear as shocked as i.
https://escapekey.substack.com/p/surveillance-capitalism
thats Zuboff’s move in the book, ‘Surveillance Capitalism’ - which completely fails to point the finger at the central bank empire.
i know, i know - do try to appear as shocked as i.
https://escapekey.substack.com/p/surveillance-capitalism
Substack
Surveillance Capitalism
Most people think enforced laws are national.
👍7💯2😁1
Zuboff, a harvard professor, writes hundreds of pages about surveillance, power, and the threat to democracy — invoking polanyi, arendt, durkheim, the new deal — and never once mentions the BIS.
she names Google's chief economist, but she doesn't name the Bank for International Settlements
she celebrates the Spanish Data Protection Agency ordering Google to de-link search results, but she doesn't mention that FATF can exclude entire nations from the global financial system through grey-listing
she calls for new public institutions to govern information, yet the public institutions that already govern financial information globally, without democratic accountability — she cannot see
shocked! absolutely shocked!
she names Google's chief economist, but she doesn't name the Bank for International Settlements
she celebrates the Spanish Data Protection Agency ordering Google to de-link search results, but she doesn't mention that FATF can exclude entire nations from the global financial system through grey-listing
she calls for new public institutions to govern information, yet the public institutions that already govern financial information globally, without democratic accountability — she cannot see
shocked! absolutely shocked!
👍9❤2😈1
re-reading this suddenly snaps me to Dan Shefet
(setting aside the overly dramatic and emotional framing)
https://escapekey.substack.com/p/the-ethical-approach?utm_source=publication-search
(setting aside the overly dramatic and emotional framing)
https://escapekey.substack.com/p/the-ethical-approach?utm_source=publication-search
if Zuboff’s concern were actually surveillance and control, central bank digital currencies would be chapter one
but… she’s never criticised CBDCs.
golly, it’s another one of them coincidences
but… she’s never criticised CBDCs.
golly, it’s another one of them coincidences
her book was published in 2019, and she hasn’t uttered a word on CBDCs, neither in that book, nor since then.
what an extraordinary coincidence!
what an extraordinary coincidence!
her solutions, in essence, are ‘new digital institutions’, ‘democratic governance of the digital’, ‘digital’, ‘digital’…
never ‘preserve cash’, ‘opt out’, ‘refuse digital id’
no, she’s essentially advocating you accept your place in the AI-run (Genesis Mission) digital empire of tomorrow
that’s ‘democratic’ to her central bank funders
never ‘preserve cash’, ‘opt out’, ‘refuse digital id’
no, she’s essentially advocating you accept your place in the AI-run (Genesis Mission) digital empire of tomorrow
that’s ‘democratic’ to her central bank funders
👍3
ok the book doesnt actually explain i can only assume it’s accounting and control, fits the bill
https://archive.org/details/UtopianThoughtInTheWesternWorld/page/20/mode/2up?q=applied+utopistics
https://archive.org/details/UtopianThoughtInTheWesternWorld/page/20/mode/2up?q=applied+utopistics
oh you mean ‘cosmopolitan democracy’?
https://escapekey.substack.com/p/cosmopolitan-democracy?utm_source=publication-search
https://escapekey.substack.com/p/cosmopolitan-democracy?utm_source=publication-search
wait, im now at page 322 of her ‘book’ and it’s still just criticism of ‘surveillance capitalism’
just like Marx!
just like Marx!
“It's like looking through the menu at a Scottish restaurant: not much in it and nothing you want”
👏1