CiteCase
Photo
Here are some quotable quotes from yesterday's #SupremeCourt judgment on caste discrimination in prison manuals:
✅Our interpretation of the Constitution must fill the silences in its text.
✅The Constitution is not just a legal document, but in India’s social structure, it is a quantum leap. In one stroke, it gave a dignified identity to all citizens of India.
✅The Constitution mandates the replacement of fundamental wrongs with fundamental rights.
✅The fight against caste-based discrimination is not a battle that can be won overnight; it requires sustained effort, dedication, and the willingness to confront and challenge societal norms that perpetuate inequality.
✅As a society that divided people into a hierarchy, we must remain conscious of the forms and kinds of discrimination against marginalized groups. Discriminatory laws enacted before the Constitution of India came into force need to be scrutinized and done away with.
✅Article 17 enunciates that everyone is born equal. There cannot be any stigma attached to the existence, touch or presence of any person.
✅A nation must prioritize human dignity—ensuring that every person, regardless of their background or identity, is able to live with respect, equality, and freedom.
✅The right to live with dignity extends even to the incarcerated. Not providing dignity to prisoners is a relic of the colonizers and pre-colonial mechanisms, where oppressive systems were designed to dehumanize and degrade those under the control of the State.
✅The rules of caste continued in medieval history. The law of caste manifested in several ways– with each manifestation causing a form of violence against the oppressed communities.
✅The exercise of the power to arrest or detain may become reflective of a colonial mindset, if not exercised with caution.
✅Discrimination against the Scheduled Castes, Scheduled Tribes, and Denotified Tribes has continued in a systemic manner. Remedying systemic discrimination requires concrete multi-faceted efforts by all institutions.
✅Segregating prisoners on the basis of caste would reinforce caste differences or animosity that ought to be prevented at the first place. Segregation would not lead to rehabilitation.
✅The notion that an occupation is considered as “degrading or menial” is an aspect of the caste system and untouchability.
✅Refusal to check caste practices or prejudices amounts to cementing of such practices. If such practices are based on the oppression of the marginalized castes, then such practices cannot be left untouched.
✅The rule that a prisoner of a high caste be allowed to refuse the food cooked by other castes is a legal sanction by the State authorities to untouchability and the caste system.”
✅Article 21 envisages the growth of individual personality. Caste prejudices and discrimination hinder the growth of one’s personality. Therefore, Article 21 provides for the right to overcome caste barriers as a part of the right to life of individuals from marginalized communities.
✅Assigning labour based on caste background strips individuals of their liberty to engage in meaningful work, and denies them the opportunity to rise above the constraints imposed by their social identity.
✅After all, the “bounds of caste are made of steel”– “Sometimes invisible but almost always inextricable””.But not so strong that they cannot be broken with the power of the Constitution.
Read more @ https://citecase.in/sukanya-shantha-vs-union-of-india-2024-insc-753-prison-manuals-caste-discrimination/
Liked this? Support us by subscribing to caseciter.com for monthly digests of #SupremeCourt judgments ! It costs you just ₹1 per day.
✅Our interpretation of the Constitution must fill the silences in its text.
✅The Constitution is not just a legal document, but in India’s social structure, it is a quantum leap. In one stroke, it gave a dignified identity to all citizens of India.
✅The Constitution mandates the replacement of fundamental wrongs with fundamental rights.
✅The fight against caste-based discrimination is not a battle that can be won overnight; it requires sustained effort, dedication, and the willingness to confront and challenge societal norms that perpetuate inequality.
✅As a society that divided people into a hierarchy, we must remain conscious of the forms and kinds of discrimination against marginalized groups. Discriminatory laws enacted before the Constitution of India came into force need to be scrutinized and done away with.
✅Article 17 enunciates that everyone is born equal. There cannot be any stigma attached to the existence, touch or presence of any person.
✅A nation must prioritize human dignity—ensuring that every person, regardless of their background or identity, is able to live with respect, equality, and freedom.
✅The right to live with dignity extends even to the incarcerated. Not providing dignity to prisoners is a relic of the colonizers and pre-colonial mechanisms, where oppressive systems were designed to dehumanize and degrade those under the control of the State.
✅The rules of caste continued in medieval history. The law of caste manifested in several ways– with each manifestation causing a form of violence against the oppressed communities.
✅The exercise of the power to arrest or detain may become reflective of a colonial mindset, if not exercised with caution.
✅Discrimination against the Scheduled Castes, Scheduled Tribes, and Denotified Tribes has continued in a systemic manner. Remedying systemic discrimination requires concrete multi-faceted efforts by all institutions.
✅Segregating prisoners on the basis of caste would reinforce caste differences or animosity that ought to be prevented at the first place. Segregation would not lead to rehabilitation.
✅The notion that an occupation is considered as “degrading or menial” is an aspect of the caste system and untouchability.
✅Refusal to check caste practices or prejudices amounts to cementing of such practices. If such practices are based on the oppression of the marginalized castes, then such practices cannot be left untouched.
✅The rule that a prisoner of a high caste be allowed to refuse the food cooked by other castes is a legal sanction by the State authorities to untouchability and the caste system.”
✅Article 21 envisages the growth of individual personality. Caste prejudices and discrimination hinder the growth of one’s personality. Therefore, Article 21 provides for the right to overcome caste barriers as a part of the right to life of individuals from marginalized communities.
✅Assigning labour based on caste background strips individuals of their liberty to engage in meaningful work, and denies them the opportunity to rise above the constraints imposed by their social identity.
✅After all, the “bounds of caste are made of steel”– “Sometimes invisible but almost always inextricable””.But not so strong that they cannot be broken with the power of the Constitution.
Read more @ https://citecase.in/sukanya-shantha-vs-union-of-india-2024-insc-753-prison-manuals-caste-discrimination/
Liked this? Support us by subscribing to caseciter.com for monthly digests of #SupremeCourt judgments ! It costs you just ₹1 per day.
CiteCase.in
Sukanya Shantha vs Union of India 2024 INSC 753 – Prison Manuals – Caste Discrimination
Summary: Writ petition challenging caste-based discrimination in the prisons in the country and offending provisions in State prison manuals- SC held: Provisions discriminate against marginalized c…
👍1
Forwarded from Supreme Court CaseCiter
If interested to subscribe to our digests @ just ₹1 per day, click:
https://wa.me/p/8076053742492635/918075088738
https://wa.me/p/8076053742492635/918075088738
"Patience may be a virtue – but ours is nearing its end."
#SupremeCourt said while it pulled up states for not issuing Ration Cards despite identification in spite of repeated orders.
All such persons who are eligible (entitled for Ration Cards/ foodgrains as per the NFSA) and have been identified as such by the respective States/Union Territories, must be issued Ration Cards before 19.11.2024. They shall also be provided with the foodgrains forthwith, the Court ordered.
#SupremeCourt said while it pulled up states for not issuing Ration Cards despite identification in spite of repeated orders.
All such persons who are eligible (entitled for Ration Cards/ foodgrains as per the NFSA) and have been identified as such by the respective States/Union Territories, must be issued Ration Cards before 19.11.2024. They shall also be provided with the foodgrains forthwith, the Court ordered.
Hello lawyers & law students 👋
If you love what we do and think that we deserves to be supported, this is what you can do.
Please try and subscribe @CaseCiter Supreme Court monthly digests and it costs you only ₹1 per day.
This is how you can do that:
1️⃣ Visit CaseCiter.com
2️⃣Read our sample digest & FAQs
3️⃣ Click on 'Subscribe now'
4️⃣ Fill up subscription form
5️⃣ Ping us on whatsapp
6️⃣ Complete payment
7️⃣ Join our subscribers group.
And then start accessing our digests.
Please share this post with your friends and colleagues who might be interested in this.
Thank you❤️
If you love what we do and think that we deserves to be supported, this is what you can do.
Please try and subscribe @CaseCiter Supreme Court monthly digests and it costs you only ₹1 per day.
This is how you can do that:
1️⃣ Visit CaseCiter.com
2️⃣Read our sample digest & FAQs
3️⃣ Click on 'Subscribe now'
4️⃣ Fill up subscription form
5️⃣ Ping us on whatsapp
6️⃣ Complete payment
7️⃣ Join our subscribers group.
And then start accessing our digests.
Please share this post with your friends and colleagues who might be interested in this.
Thank you❤️
Forwarded from Supreme Court CaseCiter
This media is not supported in your browser
VIEW IN TELEGRAM
Happy constitution day !
Flip this e-book at your own pace in caseciter.com/preamble.
If you liked it, please share your feedback to the artist who did this. (comment box is under the flip book)
Flip this e-book at your own pace in caseciter.com/preamble.
If you liked it, please share your feedback to the artist who did this. (comment box is under the flip book)
👍1