I saw that cultist John keeps both Lisa and father Garcia alive instead of possessed and uses them as his personal toys but I gotta what exactly does he do to them ——— We'll, it depends, I guess. Having them not be possessed means he gets to play with their emotions and make them feel like there's some possibility of hope. And it's partially because The Unspeakable wants to crush that hope, and partly because the real John truly doesn't want them to give up on him.