Offshore

EndGame Macro
The Headline Says 119K Jobs. The Body Says the Economy’s Losing Lift.

Once you read this report instead of treating the headline like the whole story, the optimism fades fast. The gains are narrow, the revisions cut the wrong way, and most of the signals that should strengthen in a solid labor market are either stalling or slipping.

A Labor Market That’s Moving, But Not Moving Forward

The thinness of the job growth jumps out immediately. Payrolls rose by 119k, but the BLS openly says employment has shown “little change since April.” The three month average sits at just 62k barely enough to maintain appearances. And the revisions are the real tell…July and August were revised down by 33k, with August turning slightly negative. That’s textbook late cycle behavior.

The unemployment rate nudged up to 4.4%, but the details matter more than the number. There are now 7.6 million unemployed, higher than a year ago, and the employment population ratio has slipped, a quiet sign job creation isn’t keeping up with population growth. Long term unemployment is stuck around 1.8 million, nearly a quarter of all unemployed. In a healthy cycle, that number falls. Here, it’s not.

The Only Sectors Growing Are the Ones That Grow No Matter What

A broad, confident economy adds jobs across industries. That isn’t what’s happening.

Most of September’s gains came from the same dependable trio…
•Health care (+43k)
•Food services (+37k)
•Social assistance (+14k)

These sectors grow because people age, kids need care, and public funding keeps flowing not because demand is booming.

Meanwhile, the cyclical heart of the labor market is shrinking…
•Transportation & warehousing (–25k)
•Manufacturing (–6k)
•Temporary help (–15.9k)
•Professional & business services (–20k)

These are the canaries. Temp work especially, firms cut it when they’re uneasy about the road ahead. The data is showing that unease.

People Aren’t Working More And They’re Stretching to Keep Up

If this were genuinely a strong labor market, hours would be rising and firms would be squeezing overtime before hiring more workers. Instead, hours are stuck at 34.2. Manufacturing overtime hasn’t budged. Involuntary part time work is still near 4.6 million. Multiple jobholding is up to 8.8 million. This doesn’t look like prosperity, it looks like people filling income gaps any way they can.

Wage growth isn’t telling a different story. A 0.2% monthly gain barely touches rising living costs, especially in housing, insurance, and services. This isn’t tight market wage pressure; it’s paycheck to paycheck survival.

The Weakness Is Spreading Into the Core

The slowdown isn’t limited to marginal workers, it’s broadening into groups that usually hold up longer…
•Asian unemployment jumped from 3.6% to 4.4%.
•Black unemployment is stuck at 7.5%.
•College educated unemployment climbed to 2.8%.
•Youth unemployment for ages 20–24 hit 9.2%.

These are stress fractures appearing in the center of the labor force.

And 5.9 million people say they want a job but aren’t counted as unemployed because they didn’t look recently. In a strong cycle, this pool shrinks. Here, it’s not.

Add It All Up, and the Story Doesn’t Match the Headline

Nothing in this report signals collapse but very little signals strength. The surface looks fine, but underneath you see…
•Slowing job creation
•Negative revisions
•Weak cyclical industries
•Persistent underemployment
•Stagnant participation
•Soft wages
•Rising strain across demographic groups

If you ignored the headline and only read the internals, you wouldn’t call this a strong economy. You’d call it what it is…a late cycle labor market losing altitude while the headline tries to steady the narrative.
tweet

1 view16:35