Is Tyrion actually a strategic failure? Let’s look at the track record.
I just finished the series, and I’m starting to think we’ve been sold a lie about Tyrion Lannister. We’re constantly told he’s the "intellect" of the family, but if you look at his actual results in leadership and war, his "genius" looks more like a series of lucky breaks and catastrophic miscalculations.
Here is my assessment of why Tyrion might be the most overrated strategist in Westeros:
The Myth of Blackwater Bay:
Everyone praises the wildfire trick, but let’s be real—Stannis had him beat. Tyrion was literally face-down in the dirt and his defense was collapsing. If Tywin and the Tyrells hadn't arrived at the last possible second for a "deus ex machina" save, Tyrion’s head would have been on a spike and the city would have fallen. He didn't win that battle; his father did.
The Meereen Diplomacy Blunder: When Daenerys left him in charge, he tried to "negotiate" with the Masters. He ignored the warnings of Grey Worm and Missandei (who actually knew the culture) and gave the slavers time to rebuild. It directly led to the firebombing of the city. He got played by men he thought he was smarter than.
The Casterly Rock Trap:
In Season 7, his big masterstroke was taking the Lannister ancestral home. He sent the Unsullied there, only to realize too late that Jaime had emptied the castle and moved the gold. He sacrificed an entire fleet and left his best soldiers stranded for a "win" that didn't matter.
The "Wight Hunt" Idea:
Was this the worst plan in history? Suggesting they go north of the Wall to catch a wight to show Cersei—a woman he knows better than anyone would never care. It cost Daenerys a dragon and gave the Night King the one thing he needed to break the Wall.
My Question to the sub:
Am I missing something, or is Tyrion’s reputation just based on the fact that he speaks eloquently? If you remove his witty one-liners, his actual success rate as a Hand or a General is incredibly low. Was he ever a genius, or did he just benefit from being around people who were even more chaotic than him?
Change my mind.
https://redd.it/1tcsg4y
@gameofthronesbackup
I just finished the series, and I’m starting to think we’ve been sold a lie about Tyrion Lannister. We’re constantly told he’s the "intellect" of the family, but if you look at his actual results in leadership and war, his "genius" looks more like a series of lucky breaks and catastrophic miscalculations.
Here is my assessment of why Tyrion might be the most overrated strategist in Westeros:
The Myth of Blackwater Bay:
Everyone praises the wildfire trick, but let’s be real—Stannis had him beat. Tyrion was literally face-down in the dirt and his defense was collapsing. If Tywin and the Tyrells hadn't arrived at the last possible second for a "deus ex machina" save, Tyrion’s head would have been on a spike and the city would have fallen. He didn't win that battle; his father did.
The Meereen Diplomacy Blunder: When Daenerys left him in charge, he tried to "negotiate" with the Masters. He ignored the warnings of Grey Worm and Missandei (who actually knew the culture) and gave the slavers time to rebuild. It directly led to the firebombing of the city. He got played by men he thought he was smarter than.
The Casterly Rock Trap:
In Season 7, his big masterstroke was taking the Lannister ancestral home. He sent the Unsullied there, only to realize too late that Jaime had emptied the castle and moved the gold. He sacrificed an entire fleet and left his best soldiers stranded for a "win" that didn't matter.
The "Wight Hunt" Idea:
Was this the worst plan in history? Suggesting they go north of the Wall to catch a wight to show Cersei—a woman he knows better than anyone would never care. It cost Daenerys a dragon and gave the Night King the one thing he needed to break the Wall.
My Question to the sub:
Am I missing something, or is Tyrion’s reputation just based on the fact that he speaks eloquently? If you remove his witty one-liners, his actual success rate as a Hand or a General is incredibly low. Was he ever a genius, or did he just benefit from being around people who were even more chaotic than him?
Change my mind.
https://redd.it/1tcsg4y
@gameofthronesbackup
Reddit
From the gameofthrones community on Reddit
Explore this post and more from the gameofthrones community
Look to your sins, Lord Renly. The night if dark and full of terrors.
https://redd.it/1td5xyr
@gameofthronesbackup
https://redd.it/1td5xyr
@gameofthronesbackup
We’ve spent 10+ years haggling about post-injury Jaime’s power scaling. So to avoid doing that again, I want to talk about the *realism* of it. Could an elite fighter be injured in such a way, & relearn how to become a half decent fighter again despite this handicap?
https://redd.it/1tda1pz
@gameofthronesbackup
https://redd.it/1tda1pz
@gameofthronesbackup
What do you think Tywin would have done if he had Jaime and Cersi in the act?
https://redd.it/1tdalxz
@gameofthronesbackup
https://redd.it/1tdalxz
@gameofthronesbackup
Existe algún motivo real para que durante todo matrimonio, Ned nunca le dijera a su esposa la verdad de Jon ?
https://redd.it/1tdj6e9
@gameofthronesbackup
https://redd.it/1tdj6e9
@gameofthronesbackup
Emilia Clarke Says She Was Convinced She Was ‘Meant to Die’ After Second Brain Hemorrhage During Game of Thrones
https://people.com/emilia-clarke-reflects-on-surviving-two-brain-hemorrhages-during-game-of-thrones-11975466?taid=6a0680f132982f000154ad21&utm_campaign=peoplemagazine&utm_content=new&utm_medium=social&utm_source=twitter.com
https://redd.it/1tdkeqk
@gameofthronesbackup
https://people.com/emilia-clarke-reflects-on-surviving-two-brain-hemorrhages-during-game-of-thrones-11975466?taid=6a0680f132982f000154ad21&utm_campaign=peoplemagazine&utm_content=new&utm_medium=social&utm_source=twitter.com
https://redd.it/1tdkeqk
@gameofthronesbackup