Dull Academic Incessant Liturgical Yapping: Philosophical Orations on Order & Reaction
1.83K subscribers
4.42K photos
820 videos
14 files
198 links
Posts written by a pseudointellectual moron.
Download Telegram
Skimming through this today.

America makes a lot of sense when you conceive of it as comprising, though not universally, different segments that were trying to escape various religious doctrines.

Zoar is the home of a communistic society who call themselves “Separatists,” and who founded the village in 1817, and have here become quite wealthy. They originated in Würtemberg, and, like the Harmony Society, the Inspirationists, and others, were dissenters from the Established Church. The Separatists of southern Germany were equivalent to what in New England are called “Come Outers”—protestants against the prevailing religious faith, or, as they would say, lack of faith.


Notice the directionality. "The tradition I was born into, raised in: not good enough. They lack faith. I will now go and start my own religious movement, as I know better and do have faith."

Seems like a very prideful sort of thinking, and a sort of thinking that it foundational to the American temperament.
You can't use the word "yooper." That's our word. But you can say "yoopa."
Plato, in his Republic, suggested that a wise ruler might consider the banning of plays. His reasons included the emotional manipulation of the audience and, critically, the corruption of the actor's soul; the act of pretending to be someone else was seen as a dangerous and confusing blurring of identity, creating disorder within the actor's soul.

Now, consider this idea applied to modern entertainment: if Plato hated the actor pretending on stage, imagine his reaction to video games. Plato would hate this new art form even more than he hated plays. The consumer—the one being taught and influenced by the art—is now directly stepping into that pretending role formerly occupied by the actor. He embodies an avatar and makes choices within a fictional narrative. This direct, participatory embodiment of another self is precisely what is found in the plurality, if not majority, of video games, making them the ultimate realization of the mimetic art he had objected to.

The video gamer has stepped into the position of being corrupted by both edges of Plato's criticism: he is both the manipulated and is pretending. Put down the controller.