Sentientism
13 subscribers
9 photos
66 videos
3 files
487 links
Sentientism is: Evidence, reason and moral consideration for all sentient beings
Download Telegram
"People who showed more moral consideration of nonhuman animals... tended to show more moral consideration of sentient AIs."
"A variety of... characteristics... predicted moral consideration of AIs, especially a vegan :seedling: diet..."
https://www.sentienceinstitute.org/aims-survey-2021
This could be a major milestone - following on from the Cambridge Declaration... Surely the world will listen to 470 philosophers...? https://greea.ca/en/montreal-declaration-on-animal-exploitation/ Please do what you can to share this around on #WorldAnimalDay. I've tweeted of course if you want to retweet or share those.
"Sentientism, Motivation and Philosophical Vulcans"
Fascinating paper by previous Sentientism podcast guest and FaceBook group member Luke Roelofs exploring three varieties of Sentientist moral status/scope...
- Broad: Even zero-valenced sentience (should such a thing be possible e.g. Philosophical Vulcans or photons under #panpsychism) matters
- Narrow: Only hedonically valenced sentience (e.g. suffering/pleasure) matters
- Motivational: Any sentience matters that motivates the experiencing subject to act, even if it doesn't involve suffering/pleasure.
Luke prefers the motivational version, which collapses to the narrow version if philosophcal vulcans can't exist.
It's a bit hard to imagine what it might be like to be one of these philosophical vulcans. They might express a preference for you not to torture them - but they wouldn't feel any valenced difference whether you did or not!
https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/papq.12420
(full paper is available on ResearchGate if you have a free account there: https://www.researchgate.net/.../361954014_Sentientism...).
David Chalmers has just cited us again in a talk he's giving now on whether Large Language Models are sentient :)
"What is compassion if it doesn't include all sentient beings?" I had the pleasure of joining psychologist Stan Steindl on his “Compassion in a T-shirt” series. I hope you enjoy our conversation as much as I did. Don’t forget to sub to Stan’s channel! https://youtu.be/K4Y0I7OUg7g