Chaining Freedom: The Conflict Between Use Of Handcuffs Under BNSS And Right To Life And Personal Liberty
https://www.livelaw.in/articles/chaining-freedom-the-conflict-between-use-of-handcuffs-under-bnss-and-right-to-life-and-personal-liberty-263793
https://www.livelaw.in/articles/chaining-freedom-the-conflict-between-use-of-handcuffs-under-bnss-and-right-to-life-and-personal-liberty-263793
www.livelaw.in
Chaining Freedom: The Conflict Between Use Of Handcuffs Under BNSS And Right To Life And Personal Liberty
On 1st July, 2024, the new criminal laws i.e., Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 ['BNS'], Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 ['BNSS'] and Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023 ['BSA'] have come...
Understanding E-Evidence Under Bhartiya Sakshya Adhiniyam 2023: Key Provisions And Implications
https://www.livelaw.in/know-the-law/understanding-e-evidence-under-bhartiya-sakshya-adhiniyam-2023-key-provisions-and-implications-263448
https://www.livelaw.in/know-the-law/understanding-e-evidence-under-bhartiya-sakshya-adhiniyam-2023-key-provisions-and-implications-263448
www.livelaw.in
Understanding E-Evidence Under Bhartiya Sakshya Adhiniyam 2023: Key Provisions And Implications
The three new criminal laws, the βBhartiya Nyaya Sanhita,β the βBhartiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita,β and the βBhartiya Sakshya Adhiniyam,β have replaced the Indian Penal Code (IPC), the Code of...
Behind Bars & Ballots : How Laws Apply When Jailed Persons Win Elections?
https://www.livelaw.in/top-stories/behind-bars-ballots-how-laws-apply-when-jailed-persons-win-elections-260564
@CurrentLegalGK
https://www.livelaw.in/top-stories/behind-bars-ballots-how-laws-apply-when-jailed-persons-win-elections-260564
@CurrentLegalGK
Lawyers Advertising Through Online Portals, Commodification Of Profession Against Ethical Mandate
https://www.livelaw.in/articles/lawyers-advertising-online-portals-commodification-profession-ethical-mandate-263465
https://www.livelaw.in/articles/lawyers-advertising-online-portals-commodification-profession-ethical-mandate-263465
www.livelaw.in
Lawyers Advertising Through Online Portals, Commodification Of Profession Against Ethical Mandate
In ancient Greece, Socrates warned against the sophists who, much like hawkers in a bustling marketplace, peddled their teaching services purely for profit. Fast forward to the present day, and...
Why members of the Bhil tribe have again demanded a separate βBhil Pradeshβ π
#explained_politics #express_explained #rajasthan #tribal_community
#explained_politics #express_explained #rajasthan #tribal_community
The Indian Express
Why members of the Bhil tribe have again demanded a separate βBhil Pradeshβ
While a tribal MP from Rajasthan has advocated for an independent Bhil state in western India, the BJPβs Tribal Area Development minister has spoken against it. What is the demand?
πβοΈπ
π Corresponding section- 46 CrPC
π Prem Shankar Shukla vs Delhi Administration, 1980 and Sunil batra, 1978 Guidelinesβ
1. Handcuffing is, prima facie, inhuman, unreasonable & Arbitrary.
2. Competing claims of securing the prisoner from fleeing and protecting his personality from barbarity have to be harmonized...& Other such guidelines..
SC directed UOI to make Guidelines and rules for Handcuffing use.
π Citizens For Democracy vs State Of Assam, 1995
The Supreme Court relied on its decisions in Sunil Batra and Prem Shankar Shukla cases laid down guidelines for use of handcuff and directed all ranks of police and prison authorities to meticulously obey the guidelines.
π Guidelines are as followsβ
β‘1. General rule
Handcuffs or other fetters shall not be forced on a prisoner - convicted or under-trial-while lodged in a jail anywhere in the country or while transporting or in transit from one jail to another or from jail to court and back. The police and the jail authorities, ON THEIR OWN, shall have no authority to direct the hand- cuffing of any inmate of a jail in the country or during transport from one jail to another or from jail to court and back.
2. Exceptions-
Where the police or the jail authorities have well-grounded basis for drawing a strong inference that a particular prisoner is likely to jump jail or break out of the custody
π«±then the said prisoner be produced before the Magistrate concerned and
π«±Prayer for permission to handcuff the prisoner be made before the said Magistrate.
Magistrate discretionβ
Save in rare cases of concrete proof regarding proneness of the prisoner to violence,'his tendency to escape, he being so dangerous/desperate and the finding that no other practical way of forbidding escape is available, the β Magistrate may grant permission to handcuff the prisoner.
3. Special orders required in remand order for judicial/police custody (167), execution of a warrant of arrest.
4. When police can handcuff without order of magistrate
If Person is arrested by the police without warrant the police officer concerned may if he is satisfied, on the basis of the guidelines given above (dangerous/desperate, tendency to escape etc..) that it is necessary to handcuff such a person, he may do so till the time he is taken to the police station and thereafter his production before the Magistrate. Further use of fetters thereafter can only be under the orders of
the Magistrate as already indicated above.
5. All Ranks of Police officers have to follow the above guidelines and non compliance will be dealt as contempt of court.
π Table is attached for List of Offences in which Handcuffing is allowed.
π Compensation Awarded
Sabah Al Zarid v. State of Assam, 2023 awarded Rs. 5,00,000/- compensation to the petitioner which was payable by the respondent and held the handcuffing of the petitioner by the respondent contrary to the law laid down by Supreme Court.
@CurrentLegalGK
Section 43(3) BNSS Handcuffing π Corresponding section- 46 CrPC
π Prem Shankar Shukla vs Delhi Administration, 1980 and Sunil batra, 1978 Guidelinesβ
1. Handcuffing is, prima facie, inhuman, unreasonable & Arbitrary.
2. Competing claims of securing the prisoner from fleeing and protecting his personality from barbarity have to be harmonized...& Other such guidelines..
Prem Shankar Declared the use of handcuffs unconstitutional under article 21. However, the court has carved out certain exceptions to the general practice of use of handcuffsπ Aeltemesh Rein v. Union of India, (1988)
SC directed UOI to make Guidelines and rules for Handcuffing use.
π Citizens For Democracy vs State Of Assam, 1995
The Supreme Court relied on its decisions in Sunil Batra and Prem Shankar Shukla cases laid down guidelines for use of handcuff and directed all ranks of police and prison authorities to meticulously obey the guidelines.
π Guidelines are as followsβ
β‘1. General rule
Handcuffs or other fetters shall not be forced on a prisoner - convicted or under-trial-while lodged in a jail anywhere in the country or while transporting or in transit from one jail to another or from jail to court and back. The police and the jail authorities, ON THEIR OWN, shall have no authority to direct the hand- cuffing of any inmate of a jail in the country or during transport from one jail to another or from jail to court and back.
2. Exceptions-
Where the police or the jail authorities have well-grounded basis for drawing a strong inference that a particular prisoner is likely to jump jail or break out of the custody
π«±then the said prisoner be produced before the Magistrate concerned and
π«±Prayer for permission to handcuff the prisoner be made before the said Magistrate.
Magistrate discretionβ
Save in rare cases of concrete proof regarding proneness of the prisoner to violence,'his tendency to escape, he being so dangerous/desperate and the finding that no other practical way of forbidding escape is available, the β Magistrate may grant permission to handcuff the prisoner.
3. Special orders required in remand order for judicial/police custody (167), execution of a warrant of arrest.
4. When police can handcuff without order of magistrate
If Person is arrested by the police without warrant the police officer concerned may if he is satisfied, on the basis of the guidelines given above (dangerous/desperate, tendency to escape etc..) that it is necessary to handcuff such a person, he may do so till the time he is taken to the police station and thereafter his production before the Magistrate. Further use of fetters thereafter can only be under the orders of
the Magistrate as already indicated above.
5. All Ranks of Police officers have to follow the above guidelines and non compliance will be dealt as contempt of court.
π Table is attached for List of Offences in which Handcuffing is allowed.
Is 43(3) BNSS correct as per guidelines?
π Compensation Awarded
Sabah Al Zarid v. State of Assam, 2023 awarded Rs. 5,00,000/- compensation to the petitioner which was payable by the respondent and held the handcuffing of the petitioner by the respondent contrary to the law laid down by Supreme Court.
@CurrentLegalGK
π7β€3π―3π1
MP Yearly Digest 2023 @CurrentLegalGK .pdf
104.9 MB
π4π―1π€1
Delhi Legal History .pdf
35.3 MB
π5π2β1π€©1
IPR cases Delhi High court .pdf
21.1 MB
π₯4π1
Applicability Of CrPC After July 1, 2024: A Conflict In The Twilight Zone
https://www.livelaw.in/top-stories/bnss-crpc-fir-ipc-trial-after-july-1-bnss-retrospective-accused-rights-263958
https://www.livelaw.in/top-stories/bnss-crpc-fir-ipc-trial-after-july-1-bnss-retrospective-accused-rights-263958
www.livelaw.in
Applicability Of CrPC After July 1, 2024: A Conflict In The Twilight Zone
Within days of coming into force, the much celebrated new criminal laws which repealed the "colonial remnants" have provoked a legal conundrum qua their applicability to offences registered prior...
ππΌπΎπΈπ βπββπΌβπ πΈπ½π½πΈπβπ πΉπͺ- βππ₯π¦π£ππ ππ¦π€π₯πππ β’
Applicability Of CrPC After July 1, 2024: A Conflict In The Twilight Zone https://www.livelaw.in/top-stories/bnss-crpc-fir-ipc-trial-after-july-1-bnss-retrospective-accused-rights-263958
Applicability of BNSS - CrPC far more tricky and can only be understood when 531 is understood properly.1. -For FIRs lodged and trials commenced prior to July 1 2024, CrPC will hold field (Section 531(2)(a) BNSS);
2. -For FIRs lodged prior to July 1 2024, CrPC will apply so far as investigation is concerned. But if trial commences after July 1, BNSS will apply (since CrPC will continue to apply only to "pending" trials, etc.);
3. -For offence occurred prior to enforcement of new laws but FIR lodged after July 1 2024, FIR will be under IPC but probe and trial will be under BNSS (since substantive law at the time of commission of offence will hold field but accused has no vested right to old procedure);
4. -For trials pending as on July 1 2024, appellate proceedings, if any, will be governed by BNSS (since appeal, though continuation of trial, was not "pending").
These are only a limited set of issues. In the foreseeable future, applicability of procedure for revision, quashing petitions in relation to trials or appeals pending/ concluded under CrPC are likely to emerge.
Section 528β: Inherent powers may be used to get community service in the future as punishment.
β‘π Learn itβ 531 (2) (a)
if, immediately before the date on which this Sanhita comes into force, there Is any APPEAL, APPLICATION, TRIAL, INQUIRY or INVESTIGATION pending, then, (such appeal, application, trial, inquiry or investigation) shall be disposed of, continued, held or made, as the case may be, in accordance with the provisions of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973.
ππ€ Mention the provisions related to inquiry under CrPC
@CurrentLegalGK
π12π3
Kerala High Court Revises Selection Rules For Civil Judge (Junior Division), Minimum Three Years Of Practise Needed To Apply
https://www.livelaw.in/news-updates/kerala-high-court-resolves-amend-selection-rules-civil-judge-junior-division-revises-eligibility-criteria-263963
https://www.livelaw.in/news-updates/kerala-high-court-resolves-amend-selection-rules-civil-judge-junior-division-revises-eligibility-criteria-263963
www.livelaw.in
Kerala High Court Resolves To Revise Selection Rules For Civil Judge (Junior Division), Minimum Three Years Of Practise Neededβ¦
In a Full Court meeting of judges, the Kerala High Court has resolved to carry out amendments in the Selection Rules for appointment to the post of Civil Judge (Junior Division), specifying a...
π€©2π―2
ππΌπΎπΈπ βπββπΌβπ πΈπ½π½πΈπβπ πΉπͺ- βππ₯π¦π£ππ ππ¦π€π₯πππ β’
Kerala High Court Revises Selection Rules For Civil Judge (Junior Division), Minimum Three Years Of Practise Needed To Apply https://www.livelaw.in/news-updates/kerala-high-court-resolves-amend-selection-rules-civil-judge-junior-division-revises-eligibilityβ¦
π¨ββοΈ 1990-2005 cycle is getting repeated.Experience is required because of the practical nuances.
1. Examination process tests only theory.
2. Many Law colleges are dumb they don't allow practical internships.
Experience agar hoga to subke liye hona chahiye 70% and 3 years to intelligible differentia create nahi karta π€ (Kahan 3 years w/o income practice kaha private ke 80%)
Corruption will increase now for experience and even after they get into service also (corrupt minds will enter) Talent/deserving will lose opportunity.
Observations suo Motu kabhi bhi judges ki recruitment process me gadbadi par nahi aati, jo unke bekar exam process ke karan judges baithein hain, (examination process + corruption) unke kharab knowledge ke karan ab rules change kr rhe.
The Question is how you are going to count the experience???
@CurrentLegalGK
π₯8π4π―3
ππΌπΎπΈπ βπββπΌβπ πΈπ½π½πΈπβπ πΉπͺ- βππ₯π¦π£ππ ππ¦π€π₯πππ β’
πππ¨ Announcement 15 August is the date of the 1st Anniversary of this Channel π§ Planning to Organise a Competition. π‘ Suggest us some good Ideas for competition π One competition is for sure is on logo making for our channel, if you think you can makeβ¦
π‘
βοΈYou will have only 2 hour to write and share in PDF form with your name on top.
π Date: The topic will be shared on 11th August and entries will get closed after 2 hour.
π Time limit Reason: To avoid UFM and only deserving candidates get the prize.
π Use: Prize + Compete with hundreds of candidates.
π Prize: MCQ Booklet πππ
Only to Top 3 candidates.
@CurrentLegalGK
Essay writing competition would be a great idea.
βοΈYou will have only 2 hour to write and share in PDF form with your name on top.
π Date: The topic will be shared on 11th August and entries will get closed after 2 hour.
π Time limit Reason: To avoid UFM and only deserving candidates get the prize.
π Use: Prize + Compete with hundreds of candidates.
π Prize
Only to Top 3 candidates.
Our Last Competition was Amazing, got so many entries for quiz making this time I hope we get triple entries bcz this is directly related to your mains practice Mock test.
@CurrentLegalGK
β€9π8β€βπ₯1π―1
ππΌπΎπΈπ βπββπΌβπ πΈπ½π½πΈπβπ πΉπͺ- βππ₯π¦π£ππ ππ¦π€π₯πππ β’
π‘ Essay writing competition would be a great idea. βοΈYou will have only 2 hour to write and share in PDF form with your name on top. π
Date: The topic will be shared on 11th August and entries will get closed after 2 hour. π Time limit Reason: To avoidβ¦
ππ
Also remember we need a decent long term use logo so avoid use of AI as it is prone to errors.
All the Best π―
@CurrentLegalGK
Logo Making Competition is still on keep sending.
Also remember we need a decent long term use logo so avoid use of AI as it is prone to errors.
All the Best π―
@CurrentLegalGK
π1
π #Question
In which case the Supreme Court acknowledged that the Indian Constitution had conceived a quasi federal policy?
(a) St. of Punjab V. Devans Modern Breweries Ltd.
(b) Kailash Chand V. Dharam Dass
(c) Ashok Tanwar V. St. of M.P.
(d) J. P. Bansal V. St. of Rajasthan
@CurrentLegalGK
In which case the Supreme Court acknowledged that the Indian Constitution had conceived a quasi federal policy?
(a) St. of Punjab V. Devans Modern Breweries Ltd.
(b) Kailash Chand V. Dharam Dass
(c) Ashok Tanwar V. St. of M.P.
(d) J. P. Bansal V. St. of Rajasthan
@CurrentLegalGK
π3π€©2
π Artificial intelligence Essay Legal perspective is a must in every essay whether it is social or state specific (they check your mindset and at the end being legal is good)
Your Quote should always be by a thinker, scholar or jurist. I would say Indian Judges ka hai to best hai, har jagah recent Quotes MODI, Elon Musk ye sub ke avoid krna jab tak bohot suitable na ho.
https://t.me/CurrentLegalGK/2288
Telegram
ππΌπΎπΈπ βπββπΌβπ πΈπ½π½πΈπβπ πΉπͺ- βππ₯π¦π£ππ ππ¦π€π₯πππ β’
βοΈ Artificial Intelligence - Importance in Indian Judiciary
Basic #essay Material
More: https://t.me/CurrentLegalGK/2930
@CurrentLegalGK
Basic #essay Material
More: https://t.me/CurrentLegalGK/2930
@CurrentLegalGK
π6π₯3
ππ€
βIt is an evident position of law that a prior executive decision does not bar the state legislature from enacting a law or framing a policy contrary to or in conflict with the previous executive decision in furtherance of the larger public interest. Nor can it be argued that the law laid down by the legislature would be affected by the principles of promissory estoppel or legitimate expectation because the executive had previously expressed a different view.
ο»Ώ@CurrentLegalGK
Doctrine of Legitimate Expectation / Promissory estoppel
βIt is an evident position of law that a prior executive decision does not bar the state legislature from enacting a law or framing a policy contrary to or in conflict with the previous executive decision in furtherance of the larger public interest. Nor can it be argued that the law laid down by the legislature would be affected by the principles of promissory estoppel or legitimate expectation because the executive had previously expressed a different view.
The doctrine does not elevate legitimate expectation to the level of a right enforceable by law.
Doctrine of legitimate expectation does not constrain the government from altering its policies, provided the changes are made in public interest and not through an abuse of power.
ο»Ώ@CurrentLegalGK
π6π2π―2
Elderly population in India expected to double by 2050: UNFPA India chief - https://www.thehindu.com/news/national/elderly-population-in-india-expected-to-double-by-2050-unfpa-india-chief/article68428477.ece,
The Hindu
Elderly population in India expected to double by 2050: UNFPA India chief
UNFPA India chief highlights key population trends in India, emphasizing the need for investment in healthcare and housing.
π€―4π3π1
ππΌπΎπΈπ βπββπΌβπ πΈπ½π½πΈπβπ πΉπͺ- βππ₯π¦π£ππ ππ¦π€π₯πππ β’ pinned Β«π‘ Essay writing competition would be a great idea. βοΈYou will have only 2 hour to write and share in PDF form with your name on top. π
Date: The topic will be shared on 11th August and entries will get closed after 2 hour. π Time limit Reason: To avoidβ¦Β»